Research
Radical monopoly
Illich’s term for the dominance of one way of meeting a need, until the alternatives stop working.
-
Who holds the keys to public intelligence?
Sebastian Clark wants to run AI as public infrastructure: organizations like rural American electric co-ops would own compute. Universities and hospitals would license whatever runs on their data. Clark’s plan settles who holds the keys. It never says how big…
-
Shifting baselines and the second watershed
In 1995, Daniel Pauly named the way we quietly lose track of our place in an objective decline and become blind to impending ruin: shifting baselines. They apply to systems and tools as well as fish populations. Counterfoil’s tool catalogue…
-
Why more makes less
Self-sabotage, counterproductivity, iatrogenesis, and Nemesis — from ancient to modern times, from road congestion to software, humans have described the same patterns.
-
Public interest research and counterfoil research
Nader’s PIRGs and Illich’s counterfoil research began in the same years, aimed at the same institutions. Illich read the consumer movement closely, and his objection still marks the difference.
-
What would Ivan Illich make of large language models?
Ivan Illich would ask about thresholds, call the hosted language models a radical monopoly, and relate them to the first loudspeaker that ended silence as a commons in a community of equal voices.