About


Counterfoil is a research project that asks, “Which tools leave people more capable? Which tools make them more dependent? How can we tell the difference before it is too late to change course?”

Where the name comes from

In 1973 Ivan Illich published Tools for Conviviality, a short book arguing that every tool, from a hand drill to a hospital system, has natural limits. Below a certain threshold it extends what people can do for themselves. Past that threshold it starts to do things to them: it creates dependence, demands specialists, taxes its users, introduces stressors and hidden costs, and crowds out alternatives. It may even undermine, hinder, or oppose its stated purposes.

Illich called the study of those limits “counterfoil research.” He gave it two tasks: to spot the early signs that a tool is exiting its useful threshold, and to design tools that keep a good balance. A counterfoil is also the part of a cheque, receipt, or ticket that the issuer tears off and keeps, to confirm that its counterpart is genuine and to account for the transaction. Both meanings fit: the open, informal research runs counter to research done for institutions, and it keeps an account of what our tools cost us.

For everything Illich said about counterfoil research — which wasn’t much — see What is counterfoil research?

What we do

  • Research. Short, sourced notes on the evidence about tools, scale, and limits, drawing on Illich and on the people who have extended, tested, and argued with him.
  • Catalogue. Records of specific tools, each assessed on what it does, where a tool stops serving people, how you can leave it, and where it sits relative to its threshold for healthy use. Every record carries its sources, open questions for further research, and its history.
  • Workshop. We’re building a few tools ourselves, starting with the software this site runs on. All of it is or will be free software, licensed under the GPL.

The questions we ask

Counterfoil’s working method is a set of plain questions, each drawn from a body of research:

Our first full catalogue record, the bicycle, shows how these questions work in practice. The bicycle was one of Illich’s own central examples.

How we work

  • Every claim links to a source a reader can check. Where the evidence is contested, we say so.
  • Figures have dates. A number from 1973 is reported as a number from 1973.
  • This site is built on WordPress, with no commercial plugin dependencies, and it publishes an RSS feed that openly distributes all our content in an open standard format.
  • Most of the code and writing for Counterfoil was developed with generative AI models working together under the direction of a human editor. What would Illich think about that?
  • The same goes for Counterfoil’s evaluative method, derived from Illich’s work. It’s a simple but subjective system well suited to both automation and a provocative opener for thoughtful human dialogue.

Who’s behind it

Dan Knauss Avatar

How to get in touch

To get in touch, use the contact form or try ivan@counterfoil.org.


Sources

  • Illich, Ivan. Tools for Conviviality. Calder & Boyars, 1973.

Last updated: