Received into the cataloguecounterfoil

The telephone

Provisional review Last reviewed

Not fully scored yet. This may change. How we evaluate tools

In the convivial range. Of the six balances: 4 tipping, 1 holding, 1 not assessed. Position somewhere between 63 and 85 of 100. The balances not assessed could put it past the second watershed.

  • Biological degradation Not assessed Does this tool damage the living world, or the body, faster than either can recover? Not assessed: nobody has looked at this yet, so it is not counted as holding.
  • Radical monopoly Tipping Can people still meet the need another way, without this tool? Tipping: the tool has begun to cause this problem, without going past the limit.
  • Overprogramming Holding Does using this tool require training or certification that people cannot give each other? Holding: the tool does not cause this problem.
  • Polarization Tipping Does this tool move power or advantage to a few, at others’ cost? Tipping: the tool has begun to cause this problem, without going past the limit.
  • Obsolescence Tipping Does this tool force people to replace what still works? Tipping: the tool has begun to cause this problem, without going past the limit.
  • Frustration Tipping Does this tool give back less than it takes, counting everything it takes? Tipping: the tool has begun to cause this problem, without going past the limit.
Line drawing of a rotary desk telephone with a red handset on its cradle and a curly cord.

What it does

Lets anyone with a line speak to anyone else with one, in real time, about anything. The network carries the call; it has no say in what is said.

Where it stops

At the connection. The operator runs the lines but not the conversation. It drifts toward its second watershed when machines fill the lines faster than people can, when a phone number becomes a requirement for banking and public services, or when calling needs a platform account.

How easily you can stop using it

Numbers move between carriers, and a phone built to the current standard works on the network until the carrier retires that standard. Leaving altogether has become hard. Letters and visits still carry a conversation, more slowly, but they cannot stand in where a phone number is demanded as proof of who you are.


What is scored

  • The unit: The public voice telephone network and a phone on it, fixed or mobile. Left out: the smartphone as a computer (see The smartphone), messaging apps, and the internet. Three of this record’s scores use evidence from the mobile era, because the voice network now runs mostly on mobile carriers.
  • The job it is tested against: Letting any two people with a line talk to each other in real time. It does this reliably.
  • Where and when: Canada and the United States, 2018 to 2026, for the scores; Illich’s account from 1973 for the design.

Illich chose the telephone as his example of an institution that is “structurally convivial.”1 That surprises people, because the telephone network is large, centrally administered, and built on advanced engineering. For Illich that was the point: whether a tool is convivial does not depend on how simple or how small it is, but on what it lets people do and what it demands of them.

What Illich saw

In Tools for Conviviality (1973) he set out why the telephone qualified. Anyone with the price of a call could reach the person of their choice and say whatever they liked: do business, express love, or pick a quarrel. The company runs the lines, but it cannot decide what people say to each other. Using the phone does not stop anyone else using it, it needs no certificate, and nobody is obliged to own one. He made the same claim for the mails and for a Mexican market, each very different in technology but alike in leaving people free.

He also admitted the limits. Telephone systems are built for one kind of message and must be run from the centre, even when they serve a single area. A convivial tool, he argued, can still be a large and specialized one.

The untiring computers

One sentence in Illich’s passage now reads like a forecast. If “untiring computers keep the lines occupied” and crowd out personal conversation, he wrote, that is a misuse of a licence granted so that people can speak. Half a century later, automated calls are what people complain about most. A 2020 Congressional Research Service report found that robocalls were the US Federal Communications Commission’s biggest complaint category, at more than 200,000 complaints a year and about 60 percent of all complaints it received.

The six balances

Scored as set out in How to evaluate tools. The telephone reliably does its job, so it starts in the convivial range.

  • Biological degradation: Not assessed. This record has no evidence either way for the voice network: its exchanges, cables, towers, and handsets.
  • Radical monopoly: 1. A phone number is now asked for by banks, government services, and sign-in checks, so doing without one is hard. This needs a source; see the open questions.
  • Overprogramming: 0. Making a call needs no training.
  • Polarization: 1. A few carriers hold most of the market. In Canada, Bell, Rogers, and Telus had about 89% of mobile subscribers and 91% of revenue in 2018.2
  • Obsolescence: 1. Carriers retire networks on their own schedule. The large US carriers shut down 3G in 2022, which ended service on older phones, and Bell is ending copper home phone service in some areas in November 2026.
  • Frustration: 1. Automated calls have made answering costly. In a 2020 Pew survey only 19% of Americans said they generally answer a call from an unknown number.

Where the threshold falls

In the convivial range, at 63: four of the six balances are tipping, so its position is 50 + 13. One balance is not assessed, so this is the lowest the position can be.

The telephone is past the middle of the convivial range, and moving. The network still connects anyone to anyone, and number portability means you can take your number with you when you change carriers. What has changed is the cost of answering: when a large share of calls come from machines, people stop picking up, and the tool’s central promise weakens even though nothing about its structure has changed.

This record covers the voice network. The smartphone is a different tool, with app stores, accounts, and an advertising business attached, and it has its own record.

Open questions

  • Find a source for how often a phone number is required for banking, government services, and signing in, and replace the 2018 market-share figures with the CRTC’s latest.
  • How much has call answering actually fallen, and is there good data on it? Canadian figures from the CRTC would make a useful comparison.
  • What happens to the convivial structure as carriers retire copper landlines and move voice onto internet networks?
  • Should the smartphone be catalogued as one tool or several?

Notes

  1. Ivan Illich, Tools for Conviviality (London: Calder & Boyars, 1973), chap. 2, “Convivial Reconstruction,” 32. ↩︎
  2. CRTC figures, as reported in “CRTC Communications Monitoring Report 2018,” MobileSyrup, December 16, 2019, https://mobilesyrup.com/2019/12/16/crtc-communications-monitoring-report-2018/. ↩︎

Sources

Review history

  1. Rescored at 57 from 62 when the six balances were recorded. The earlier position was set by judgement.
  2. Moved from 57 to 63 when the method changed: a tool with every balance holding now sits at 50, the centre of the convivial range. The scores did not change.
  3. Marked provisional. The radical monopoly score still needs a source, so the record is not fully reviewed.
  4. The “where it stops” and “how easily you can stop using it” fields said nobody is obliged to own a phone and that leaving is easy, against the record’s own radical monopoly and obsolescence scores. Rewritten to agree with them.
  5. Says at the top that this is the voice network and not the smartphone, which now has its own record.
  6. Biological degradation changed from holding to not assessed. The record gave no evidence for it. The position is now shown as a range from 63.

Record last updated


Related tools

  • Catalogue · Communication

    The smartphone

    Established

    Puts a telephone, a camera, a map, a wallet, and a general-purpose computer in a pocket, always connected, with its software supplied through its maker’s store.

    No. 020
  • Catalogue · Communication · Learning

    Local language models

    Emerging

    Produces text in response to text, on a computer you control, with no connection to its maker. It works by predicting likely next words from patterns found in a very large body of writing.

    No. 019
  • Catalogue · Communication

    The fediverse

    Emerging

    Lets people on thousands of separately run servers follow and reply to each other, using a shared open protocol. Posts arrive in the order they were written; no company ranks them.

    No. 017