A dividend is not a liberty

Philipp Humm wants a shrinking, richer society to own a share of its AI and pay every citizen a dividend. Ivan Illich asked a harder question about life after employment: who can still do anything useful without a job?

Line drawing of a simple frame loom with a half-woven cloth, and a red shuttle lying idle on the floor beside it.

“If every instrument could accomplish its own work,” Aristotle wrote in the Politics, and if “the shuttle would weave” by itself, “chief workmen would not need servants, nor masters slaves.” Philipp Humm opens a November essay in Noema with that passage and asks the question it raises now. What happens to a society whose economy, welfare state, and sense of purpose all rest on wages, once machines can do most of the paid work?1 Humm is an artist in Milan who used to run T-Mobile, Vodafone, and Amazon.de. He has seen the auto-loom from the owner’s side.

What Humm proposes

Humm’s answer starts with demography. Suppose a rich country’s population falls by around 30 per cent over several decades while AI and robots cut the demand for labour by about the same amount. Fewer people need fewer jobs, so the ratio of workers to everyone else holds steady. He calls this the “30/30 equilibrium” and is careful about its limits: “it does not create prosperity.” Prosperity would have to come from more and better machines for each remaining worker. Borrowing the ecologist Eugene Odum’s distinction between fast-growing pioneer forests and mature climax forests that grow little but hold more, he argues that rich societies could learn to “shrink rich.”2

Then he asks who gets the gains. Under today’s ownership, Humm writes, “The gains will accrue primarily to the owners of capital, not to labor.” He calls universal basic income a pharmakon, “remedy and poison at the same time,” and recalls the Speenhamland system of 1795, a wage supplement that “was intended as relief” but subsidized low-paying employers and deepened the poor’s dependence on local authorities. His alternative starts from the fact that AI is trained on books, papers, public archives, and other shared work, and runs on public research and infrastructure. He calls that inheritance a “civilizational commons.” Governments should take equity stakes in AI infrastructure and pay the proceeds to every citizen as a universal capital dividend.3

Humm ends on two harder problems. One is meaning: following Hannah Arendt and David Graeber, he worries that a society organized around work won’t know what to do without it. The other is judgment: “Every delegation begins as a convenience and may end in dependency.” If both go well, “We might finally become Homo curans.” If not, we become “second-class decision-makers in a world optimized by machines,” or Homo algorithmus. Which one, he concludes rather optimistically, “will not be decided by technology, but by us.”4

What he gets right

This is a better essay than most about AI and work. Humm doesn’t treat growth as the goal; he wants a society “that has learned to distinguish growth from prosperity.” He admits the Jevons paradox (“Why more makes less”) means that cheaper intelligence will mean more of it and that “Abundance comes at a high cost to the physical world.” His line about delegation is a fair statement of what Illich called counterproductivity. Patrick Tanguay, who flagged the essay in Sentiers, adds a point Humm misses: a population 30 per cent smaller will also consume less, so holding GDP steady may matter less than Humm assumes.5

Unemployment as a liberty

Illich worked through Humm’s question nearly fifty years ago. The Right to Useful Unemployment (1978), which he called a postscript to Tools for Conviviality, begins where Humm ends: it considers what people do when there is no job for them. His complaint was that industrial society had made the question hard to even ask. “Unemployment means sad idleness,” he wrote, “rather than the freedom to do things that are useful for oneself or for one’s neighbour.” And “Work done off the paid job is looked down upon if not ignored.”6

Humm still treats a life without a job as a problem to be solved from above: income by dividend, and meaning by some answer society will have to find for “how to cultivate lives that remain meaningful outside employment.” Illich would say people already know how to make their lives meaningful. What they have lost is the ability to do it, because “the multiplication of commodities induces impotence, the incapacity to grow food, to sing, or to build.”7 A dividend doesn’t give that back. It pays people to buy what they can no longer make.

Illich drew the line between rights and liberties: “Liberties protect use-values as rights protect the access to commodities.” A universal capital dividend is a right of access, and a generous one. It is not a liberty. It makes every citizen a shareholder in the machine and leaves every citizen as dependent on it as before, now by cheque instead of paycheque. Illich’s own example: “Milking the family goat was a liberty until more ruthless planning made it a duty to contribute the yield to the GNP.”8

Who counts as a dependent

Humm’s case for wages includes a striking figure. Every hour of paid work, he writes, supports about nine hours of non-working life, including that of “children, students, retirees, homemakers and other dependents.” Illich would have stopped at the word homemakers. In Shadow Work (1981), he argued that the modern housewife’s unpaid toil is “a necessary condition for the family wage earner to exist,” and that such shadow work “might be even more fundamental” than wage labour itself. He counted commuting and much of schooling as the same kind of unpaid work.9 The wage didn’t carry that work. That work carried the wage. An economy that loses its wages won’t lose its shadow work, and it’s fair to ask Humm whether his dividend would pay for it, ignore it, or hand it to a new profession.

Homo curans or Homo curatus

That last option is the one to worry about, because care is where Humm hopes we’ll end up. He never defines Homo curans, but the Latin name means “the human who cares,” from the same root as curator. Illich spent much of the 1970s describing what happened when care became a profession. The new specialists, he wrote, “tend to wear the mask of [care] and to provide some form of care;” they are also more entrenched than any Byzantine bureaucracy.10 By 1981 he had made this into a principle: “Limits on care had to be envisaged as the necessary complement to limits on goods.”11 A post-labour society that puts care at its centre without such limits is likely to produce a dependent and passive Homo curatus: the human who is cared for, assessed, and served.12

Owning the loom

Like Sebastian Clark’s Plan for Public Intelligence, which I reviewed in “Who holds the keys to public intelligence?,” Humm makes ownership the central question: who should hold the shares when the machines do the work? Again, Illich interjects a warning about the need for hard and absolute limits: “certain tools are destructive no matter who owns them,”13 so they should not exist at all. Humm names the Jevons paradox but proposes no limit on the machines themselves. His dividend grows as AI infrastructure earns more, so every citizen would have a stake in the next expansion. Illich saw that coming too: “Excessive forms of wealth and prolonged formal employment, no matter how well distributed, destroy the social, cultural, and environmental conditions for equal productive freedom.” Illich’s alternative, which he called convivial austerity, “so [severely] limits the use of any tool that tool ownership would lose much of its present power.”14 Few will choose such austerity. It is more likely to be forced on us by a disaster that makes even subsistence uncertain.

Humm closes by saying the choice between Homo curans and Homo algorithmus is up to us, a choice that assumes an audience of united, high-agency individuals. Illich would likely agree the responsibility falls to us, but he’d ask what we can still do for ourselves. A universal capital dividend makes everyone a shareholder in the self-weaving loom. Illich wanted to know who still knows how to weave.

Notes

  1. Philipp Humm, “How Aristotle Anticipated the AI Era,” Noema, November 5, 2026. Humm ran Amazon Germany, T-Mobile Germany, and T-Mobile USA, and was Vodafone’s chief executive for Europe until 2015: Eurofiber Group, “Philipp Humm Appointed Non-Executive Board Member and Chairman of Eurofiber Group,” press release, May 24, 2016. He has worked full-time as an artist since 2015: Philipp Humm, artist’s website. ↩︎
  2. Humm, “How Aristotle Anticipated the AI Era,” sec. “Shrinking Rich.” ↩︎
  3. Humm, sec. “Who Inherits the Loom?” ↩︎
  4. Humm, sec. “The Devil in Paradise.” ↩︎
  5. Humm, sec. “Shrinking Rich”; Patrick Tanguay, “Building the ‘New Equilibrium’ Economy ⊗ Let the Internet Die,” Sentiers, no. 425, November 15, 2026. ↩︎
  6. Ivan Illich, The Right to Useful Unemployment and Its Professional Enemies (London: Marion Boyars, 1978), foreword and chap. 4, “Equity in Useful Unemployment.” ↩︎
  7. Illich, Right to Useful Unemployment, chap. 1, sec. “The Modernization of Poverty”; Humm, sec. “The Invention of Homo Faber.” ↩︎
  8. Illich, Right to Useful Unemployment, chap. 3, sec. “Liberties versus Rights.” ↩︎
  9. Humm, sec. “The Invention of Homo Faber”; Ivan Illich, Shadow Work (Boston: Marion Boyars, 1981), introduction and chap. 1, “The Three Dimensions of Public Choice.” ↩︎
  10. Illich, Right to Useful Unemployment, chap. 2, sec. “Professional Dominance.” ↩︎
  11. Illich, Shadow Work, introduction. He is describing the argument of Deschooling Society (1971). ↩︎
  12. Humm’s Latin has Hebrew precedents in Genesis. The first human is put in the garden “to till it and keep it” (Gen. 2:15), where “keep” is shamar, and Cain asks whether he is his brother’s shomer (שׁוֹמֵר), or keeper (Gen. 4:9). The woman made in Genesis 2:18 is an ʿezer (עֵזֶר), a helper or partner. Elsewhere God is rachum (רַחוּם), compassionate (Exod. 34:6), and the devout are anshei chesed (אַנְשֵׁי חֶסֶד), people of steadfast kindness (Isa. 57:1). ↩︎
  13. Ivan Illich, Tools for Conviviality (London: Calder & Boyars, 1973), chap. 2, “Convivial Reconstruction.” ↩︎
  14. Illich, Right to Useful Unemployment, foreword, and chap. 1, sec. “The History of Needs.” ↩︎

Sources

Dan Knauss Avatar

New research and catalogue records by email. Every email has a one-click unsubscribe link.

Leave a Reply

Your post must include a link to this post.

How does this work?
Write a response on your own website and include a link to this post. Then submit your response’s URL here. Your response may appear here after moderation. To update or remove it, edit or delete your original post and submit the same URL again. Learn more about Webmentions.