Research
Illich
Posts that draw on Ivan Illich (1926–2002), whose Tools for Conviviality gives this site its questions.
-
A dividend is not a liberty
Philipp Humm wants a shrinking, richer society to own a share of its AI and pay every citizen a dividend. Ivan Illich asked a harder question about life after employment: who can still do anything useful without a job?
-
Who holds the keys to public intelligence?
Sebastian Clark wants to run AI as public infrastructure: organizations like rural American electric co-ops would own compute. Universities and hospitals would license whatever runs on their data. Clark’s plan settles who holds the keys. It never says how big…
-
Before the second watershed
Ivan Illich proposed counterfoil research to detect the corruption of useful, widely adopted technologies before the rot set in. (Think Cory Doctorow’s “enshittification” in webtech.) Let’s look at where that early corruption lies on the road to Illich’s second watershed.…
-
Nemesis, the goddess of limits
The Greeks worshipped Nemesis as a goddess of equity and equilibrium — the balance of life within limits. Over two thousand years, Nemesis shrank into a word for revenge. Today she returns as a term for the structural, endemic harm…
-
Why more makes less
Self-sabotage, counterproductivity, iatrogenesis, and Nemesis — from ancient to modern times, from road congestion to software, humans have described the same patterns.
-
Elinor Ostrom and the open source commons
Ostrom showed that people can govern a shared resource without a sovereign or a market. Her eight principles, read as questions for WordPress, and what Illich adds.
-
Carl Hedman, 1934–2026
Carl was a philosopher at UWM who had worked on cooperative neighbourhood projects since the 1960s. He introduced me to Ivan Illich’s work as we both volunteered our labour on Saturday mornings.
-
Public interest research and counterfoil research
Nader’s PIRGs and Illich’s counterfoil research began in the same years, aimed at the same institutions. Illich read the consumer movement closely, and his objection still marks the difference.
-
Tools or systems?
This catalogue assumes that its subjects are tools and that someone can stand outside them.
-
Judge a tool by what it does
Illich’s “counterproductivity” and Stafford Beer’s “the purpose of a system is what it does” reach the same destination by different roads. Justin Warren puts the same tests to work on open source.
-
Holding, tipping, lost
How do you tell a tipping scale from one that’s tipped over? This is the first test for our catalogue’s evolving method, where we use the terms holding, tipping, and lost. Let’s look at one example of each and what…
-
Ellul, Charbonneau, and Illich
Illich called Jacques Ellul his master. Ellul said his best-known book belonged as much to Bernard Charbonneau as Ellul himself. What the two men from Bordeaux saw first, and what Illich did with their ideas.
-
What would Ivan Illich make of large language models?
Ivan Illich would ask about thresholds, call the hosted language models a radical monopoly, and relate them to the first loudspeaker that ended silence as a commons in a community of equal voices.
-
What is “counterfoil research?”
Ivan Illich used this phrase in four books between 1971 and 1974 but never fully defined it. Read together with the questions this site starts from, Illich’s remarks about counterfoil research concern the public study of how tools and technological…
-
Limits are a design brief
For tool design, limits and scope are not obstacles to engineer around; they define the most essential features — the ones that will not be included.
-
How many people can a tool serve?
Dunbar’s number is contested, but the finding behind it is not: human social capacity is finite and layered. Tools that ignore the layers work against the grain.
-
Small is beautiful, fifty years on
Schumacher and Illich both published books about scale in 1973. Schumacher’s idea of “intermediate technology” adds a complementary test to Illich’s counterfoil research: is a tool capable, yet simple enough for its users to maintain?
-
No mother tongue
Illich grew up with several living languages and said he had no mother tongue. His distinction between learned vernacular speech and a taught, standard language shapes how we understand literacy.